Artículos
Factors affecting maternal satisfaction with vaginal delivery: a qualitative study
Factores que afectan la satisfacción materna con el parto vaginal: un estudio cualitativo
Factors affecting maternal satisfaction with vaginal delivery: a qualitative study
Revista Latinoamericana de Hipertensión, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 277-283, 2019
Sociedad Latinoamericana de Hipertensión
Abstract:
Introduction: Bestowing a maternity identity, childbirth is considered as one of the most beautiful, though stressful, events of life for every woman. Thus, maternal satisfaction with the experience of childbirth plays a determinative role in maintaining the mental health of family and society as a decisive indicator for evaluating the quality of childbirth services. The present qualitative study intended to determine factors affecting women’s satisfaction with vaginal delivery. Materials and Methodology: To this end, the present qualitative study was conducted on hospitalized women in Fatemieh (PBUH) hospital affiliated to Hamedan University of Medical Sciences, Booali private hospital and Atieh hospital affiliated to Social Security Organization in Hamedan province. Subjects were selected based on purposive sampling method. The required data were collected through a semi-structured interview with 15 women, who had already undergone vaginal delivery. The data were analyzed based on content analysis method. Results: Once data analyzed, seven themes on women’s experiences of factors affecting their satisfaction with vaginal delivery were extracted from the contents. The extracted themes included the ‘’desire to record the unique experience of childbirth’’, ‘’underlying cultural beliefs on childbirth’’, ‘’understanding the nature of labour pain’’, ‘’confrontation with ignorance’’, ‘’interaction environment: from support to violence’’, ‘’confrontation with fear and anxiety’’ and ‘’desire to hug a healthy baby.’’ Discussion and Conclusion: The results of the present study accentuated the necessity of appropriate cultural strategies for implementing effective interventions to enhance maternal satisfaction with vaginal delivery and promoting them in accordance with the main objectives of Iran health system so as to meet WHO standards of reducing C-section delivery rates.
Keywords: Vaginal Delivery, Satisfaction, Qualitative Study.
Resumen:
Introducción: otorgando una identidad de maternidad, el parto es considerado como uno de los eventos más hermosos, aunque estresantes, de la vida de todas las mujeres. Por lo tanto, la satisfacción materna con la experiencia del parto juega un papel determinante en el mantenimiento de la salud mental de la familia y la sociedad como un indicador decisivo para evaluar la calidad de los servicios de parto. El presente estudio cualitativo tuvo como objetivo determinar los factores que afectan la satisfacción de las mujeres con el parto vaginal. Materiales y metodología: Con este fin, el presente estudio cualitativo se realizó en mujeres hospitalizadas en el hospital Fatemieh (PBUH) afiliado a la Universidad de Ciencias Médicas de Hamedan, al hospital privado Booali y al hospital Atieh afiliado a la Organización de la Seguridad Social en la provincia de Hamedan. Los sujetos fueron seleccionados en base al método de muestreo intencional. Los datos requeridos se recopilaron a través de una entrevista semiestructurada con 15 mujeres que ya habían sido sometidas a parto vaginal. Los datos fueron analizados en base al método de análisis de contenido. Resultados: Una vez analizados los datos, se extrajeron de los contenidos siete temas sobre las experiencias de las mujeres de los factores que afectan su satisfacción con el parto vaginal. Los temas extraídos incluyeron el "deseo de registrar la experiencia única del parto", "las creencias culturales subyacentes sobre el parto", "entender la naturaleza del dolor de parto", "confrontación con la ignorancia", "interacción medio ambiente: del apoyo a la violencia '', '' confrontación con miedo y ansiedad '' y '' deseo de abrazar a un bebé sano ''. Discusión y conclusión: Los resultados del presente estudio acentuaron la necesidad de estrategias culturales apropiadas para implementar intervenciones efectivas para mejorar la satisfacción materna con el parto vaginal y promoverlas de acuerdo con los principales objetivos del sistema de salud de Irán para cumplir con los estándares de la OMS de reducción de C tasas de entrega en sección.
Palabras clave: Parto vaginal, Satisfacción, Estudio cualitativo.
Introduction
Pregnancy and childbirth are two natural physiological phenomena that are among the amazing life events for every mother. Bestowing a maternity identity, childbirth is a divine, though stressful, event of life for every woman with effective impacts on their quality of life2. Moreover, childbirth is a multidimensional experience3 with unparalleled pain, emotional tension, fatigue, Vulnerability, risk of physical harm or even death, and behavioral role changes4. During childbirth, women gain important experiences that accompany them throughout their life5,6. The concept of satisfaction has nowadays got an utmost prominence in the healthcare system7. Indeed, client satisfaction refers to one’s overall attitude and inclination towards their entire healthcare experience. Satisfaction is attained once the patient’s/client’s perceived quality of healthcare services not only remains positive and satisfactory but also meets and surpasses their expectations. Accordingly, the awareness of one’s attitude towards health services has been projected as a new era in ensuring the quality of healthcare in the recent years8. Childbirth is known as a multifactorial phenomenon comprising physical, emotional, physiological, social, cultural and psychological dimensions affected by various personal and environmental factors9. Women’s satisfaction with the experience of childbirth plays a determinative role in maintaining the mental health of family and society as a decisive indicator for evaluating the quality of childbirth services. Since childbirth is the main reason of referring pregnant women to healthcare units for receiving health services, evaluation of their satisfaction with the provided cares during labour pain and delivery has become a dominant issue in assessing the quality of healthcare services and policies as well as appropriacy propriety? of healthcare decision-making and management3. With regard to the fact that one can simultaneously feel dissatisfied with some aspects of a satisfactory experiences, the overall satisfaction with delivery experience should not be solely sought in childbirth evaluation; that is factors affecting satisfaction with childbirth in different cultures should also be considered. The ultimate proposed objective of Iran healthcare system is to succeed in complying with WHO standards of reducing C-section delivery rates through promoting vaginal delivery. The fact that evaluation of childbirth satisfaction amongst Iranian women, who are living in a distinct cultural context is dissimilar to other parts of the world, has become a research priority in Iran. Thus, further investigations into maternal satisfaction with childbirth seems necessary in order to meet the country’s healthcare needs for improving fertility rate and achieve the proposed objectives through prompting women towards vaginal delivery and promoting fertility. Furthermore, since childbirth is a unique experience involving sophisticated emotions11 and in-depth qualitative data, it requires profound understanding to evaluate women’s expectations for and/or satisfaction with this exceptional process. Preceding research have had an objective and quantitative assessment on maternal satisfaction with childbirth; thus, no qualitative study has been found in this area. Some studies, however, investigated maternal satisfaction as a sub-outcome lacking sufficient depth and breadth12. Consequently, the present study aimed at determining the women’s experience and perception of factors affecting their satisfaction with childbirth.
Materials and methods
The present qualitative study was conducted based on conceptual content analysis. As a systematic technique, content analysis underlines personal experiences and attitudes in order to derive an in-depth description of the intended phenomenon13. This rule-governed research method is used for encoding and categorizing textual data to identify their overt or covert themes and patterns15,16. Data collection have commenced since June 2017 once the present research was approved under the number IR.UMSHA.REC.1396.2688 by ethics committee and letter of recommendations received from the university. Purposive sampling methods was used for targeting and selecting the subjects who are rich source of information so as to be able to actively participate in the research and provide a better description to the researcher. The number of subjects had not been exactly determined since the commence of the present research; so convenience sampling continued to data saturation in Fatemieh (PBUH) hospital affiliated to Hamedan University of Medical Sciences, Booali private hospital and Atieh hospital affiliated to Social Security Organization in Hamedan province and terminated as it reached a total number of 15 participants. Inclusion criteria consisted of mentally-balanced maternal women without a history of psychiatric diseases who were willing to participate in the research once thoroughly informed of the current objectives. The intended participants were selected with maximum demographical diversity. Moreover, data collection instrument included an in-depth semi-structured personal interview. Each interview took 20 to 60 minutes depending on the responsiveness of the participants. Accordingly, the present study performed 17 interviews with 15 participants (i.e. participants 1 and 2 both were interviewed twice). The purpose of the present study was thoroughly explained to the eligible participants by the researcher after conversing with them. Next, if they felt OKEY after the baby was delivered they were interviewed in the breastfeeding room of the same ward with cooperation of the staff. Otherwise, the participants coordinated with interviewers to decide on the time and place of the remaining interviews. Finally, the interviews were carried out at the appointed time and place once consent reached with emphasis on optional participation and the interviewees were assured of the confidentiality of their information and responses, accessibility of the findings and their right to withdraw from at any stage of participation in the present study.
Typical questions were as follows: Please explain your experience and feelings of vaginal delivery, (what do you think of your experience of delivery)? Why did you select or what affected your selection of vaginal delivery? What was effective in choosing this hospital for your childbirth? What makes you feel good about your childbirth? What are your most important concerns while thinking of your childbirth? What makes you feel bad about your childbirth? What makes you concerned about your future fertility since the time you delivered? What do you think you should have already known or been provided with to feel satisfied or dissatisfied with your current delivery? After data analysis, the subsequent participants were interviewed with different questions based on the concepts and questions aroused in the researcher’s mind to enable them achieve other dimensions and characteristics of the structured subthemes. Furthermore, exploratory questions were proposed during the interview to enrich the analysis. Such exploratory questions included: Would you please elaborate more on that? Did you mean … by saying …? Would you please clarify? In case of a second interview with the same interviewee, the subsequent questions were asked for more transparency: As discussed earlier, you told that …, would you explain more? Is there any other points you would like to add to what you have already mentioned in your previous interview?
Data analysis was simultaneously performed with data collection on the basis of conceptual content analysis. All the interviews were recorded on a voice recorder once permitted by the interviewees. The recorded interviews were literally transcribed on an MS Word file. Afterwards, the transcriptions were carefully reviewed by the researcher and were initially encoded based on semantic units. The semantic units were severally severely appraised and classified based on their conceptual homogeneity. The themes and subthemes were compared and analyzed to extract inferences.
The scientific accuracy and reliability of data were assessed in accordance with acceptability, reliability, transferability and verification criteria. Data validation was carried out through having long-term involvement with data and having sufficient time for data collection and data analysis in order to obtain more profound data and select more experienced participants. The researcher audited the research team and participants. Data verification was performed through regular data collection and accurate recording of all research stages while data reliability was attained using participant review technique. Several meetings were held with the research team for discussing the collected information to ensure data reliability. Sampling was done with maximum diversity and the details of study, its background and terms of participation were explicated to promote data transferability17,18.
Results
(Table 1) displays the demography of participants i.e. 15 women who had already undergone childbirth. Subsequently, seven themes, with 20 sub-themes included, were structured once data was analyzed. The extracted themes included the ‘’desire to record the unique experience of childbirth’’, ‘’underlying cultural beliefs on childbirth’’, ‘’understanding of the nature of labour pain’’, ‘’confrontation with ignorance’’, ‘’interaction environment: from support to aggression’’, ‘’confrontation with fear and anxiety’’ and ‘’desire to hug a healthy baby.’’
Table 1: Demography of the intended participants | |||||||||||
Participant | Age (Years) | Education | Occupation | Marital Duration | Number of Deliveries | Number of Children | Newborn’s Sex | Hospital | Mode of Delivery | With/Without Analgesia | Satisfaction |
1 | 31 | Elementary | Housewife | 11 | 3 | 3 | Girl | F[1] | Vaginal | Without Analgesia | Satisfied |
2 | 26 | Associate Degree | Employed | 4 | 1 | 1 | Girl | SS[2] | Vaginal | Epidural | Satisfied |
3 | 40 | Elementary | Housewife | 23 | 3 | 3 | Girl | F | Vaginal | Epidural | Unsatisfied |
4 | 29 | Diploma | Housewife | 7 | 1 | 1 | Girl | SS | Vaginal | Entonox Gas | Satisfied |
5 | 27 | Bachelor’s Degree | Housewife | 8 | 1 | 1 | Boy | BA[3] | Vaginal | Without | Satisfied |
6 | 27 | Diploma | Housewife | 2 | 1 | 1 | Boy | SS | Vaginal | Analgesia | Satisfied |
7 | 29 | Junior High school | Housewife | 6 | 2 | 2 | Boy | F | Vaginal | Without | Satisfied |
8 | 30 | Diploma | Housewife | 7 | 2 | 1 | Boy | F | Vaginal | Analgesia | Satisfied |
9 | 25 | Diploma | Housewife | 3 | 2 | 1 | Boy | F | Vaginal | Without | Unsatisfied |
10 | 32 | Elementary | Housewife | 17 | 5 | 4 | Boy | F | Vaginal | Analgesia | Satisfied |
11 | 19 | Diploma | Housewife | 1 | 1 | 1 | Girl | F | Vaginal | Without | Satisfied |
12 | 39 | Diploma | Housewife | 20 | 3 | 3 | Girl | F | Vaginal | Epidural | Unsatisfied |
13 | 36 | Junior Highschool | Housewife | 14 | 4 | 2 | Girl | F | Vaginal | Entonox Gas | Satisfied |
14 | 28 | Associate Degree | Employed | 11 | 3 | 2 | Girl | F | Vaginal | Epidural | Unsatisfied |
15 | 28 | Bachelor’s Degree | Employed | 4 | 1 | 1 | Boy | F | Vaginal | Epidural | Unsatisfied |
Atieh Hospital affiliated to Social Security Organization
Booali private hospital
Desire to record the unique experience of childbirth
This theme consisted of three sub-themes, namely the ‘’enthusiasm for experiencing labour pain’’, ‘’would-be mother’s consciousness and personal control over all labour procedures during delivery’’ and the ‘’love for vaginal delivery.’’ Amongst the participants, the one with an enthusiasm for experiencing the labour pain as a lovely experience stated that: ‘’It was all fine with pain, of course. Thinking of it, I believe it was so lovely and worth the pain.’’
One mother whose consciousness and personal control during delivery played a critical role in her satisfaction with childbirth experience specified that: ‘’the pain was perhaps annoying but not that much, now that I think, to brag about it and say it was too painful that I could literally talk, it seemed not too much pain to me that I could talk and stay awaked at that moment.’’
Some mothers mentioned that their decisiveness in having a vaginal delivery during pregnancy and their love for vaginal delivery had a crucial role in the satisfaction with their childbirth. Vaginal delivery was the one and only choice for most of them and was preferred to C-section delivery. In this regard, a mother expressed that: ‘’caesarean is good but not as vaginal delivery. In vaginal, you somehow feel the pain for a couple of hours but soon after you can get up and breastfeed your baby. You walk around comfortably but that’s not the case in caesarean. Generally, vaginal is more comfortable. Since the time I noticed I’m pregnant I’ve been thinking of vaginal delivery.’’
Underlying cultural beliefs on childbirth
This theme involved three subthemes as ‘’labour pain helps endure life difficulties’’, ‘’belief on the hardship of labor pain’’ and ‘’tendency to follow medical instructions.’’ Some participants had such feelings as getting older, becoming more patient and being more tolerant of life difficulties once they underwent the labor pain, which increased their satisfaction with vaginal delivery. According to a mother who felt becoming more tolerant of life hardships: ‘’It feels like as if you get older and you can tolerate more difficulties because nothing is harder and more painful than this, I believe. So you can endure any hardship in life.’’
The tendency to follow medical instructions, such as attracting the midwife’s attention by heartily listening to her commands, also played a crucial role in satisfaction with vaginal delivery. In this regard, a mother stated that: ‘’I was all ear like kids listening to them. I admitted whatsoever they told me. You know because I felt they are honestly helping me so I should be more careful.’’
Inattentiveness to the advices of others was one of the factors affecting satisfaction with vaginal delivery. A mother declared that: ‘’I never talked about it with anyone even my sister or sister-in-law. I never asked about how the pain fells like or how it goes on or what steps are there to give birth. I searched it on the net but never asked anyone. I was cool with it.’’
Understanding the nature of labour pain
The above-titled theme included three sub-themes i.e. ‘’fearful labour pain’’, ‘’progressive labour pain’’ and ‘’irresistible labour pain.’’ Many participants expressed more fears and anxiety about vaginal delivery due to their awareness of delivery stages and process through watching videos of vaginal birth, which affected their satisfaction with childbirth. However, a mother, who preferred to remain unnoticed of how vaginal delivery proceeds, declared that:
‘’If I learnt about it, I’d be more stressful. So I would like to step into it as a fait accompli.’’
Some women assumed progressiveness and irresistibility as the integral parts of labour pain. For instance, a mother asserted that:
‘’Yeah, vaginal is expected to be painful. Midwives stay up all the day through besides you as much as they can, they nurse you in any way possible but you should tolerate the pain; you know, as you make your bed, you must lie on it.’’
Confrontation with ignorance
This theme involved three sub-themes including ‘’unfamiliarity with persons and relationships’’, ‘’unfamiliarity with childbirth procedures and rules’’ and ‘’unfamiliarity with the hospital environment.’’ That is, participants considered unfamiliarity with persons and relationships, such as unfamiliarity with the nursing midwife, as a reason for dissatisfaction with childbirth.
‘’Nobody has told me who my midwife is. They were not one or two around; students come and go and I felt too bad that I had no idea who is around or who the doctor is.’’
A mother, who was unfamiliar with the childbirth procedures and rules, such as ignorance of the succor of an assistant midwife until the delivery time, stated that: ‘’I was not informed I would have an assistant midwife until yesterday when I was about to deliver.’’
Unfamiliar with the hospital environment, another would-be mother felt unsupported and imprisoned in the labour pain room and affirmed that: ‘’I felt imprisoned and alienated. They left me in a solitary room where I was not allowed to leave.’’
Interaction environment: from support to aggression
The above-titled theme encompassed four subthemes, namely ‘’pleasant environment’’, ‘’supportive interaction’’, ‘’aggressive interactions’’ and ‘’staff negligence.’’ Interaction environment implies that participants’ needs surpass the mere medical and midwifery requirements to undertake the delivery process meaning that a pleasant environment involving being understood and having an experience of environmental satisfaction as well as supportive interaction comprising longer relationship with the delivery agent had significant impacts on their satisfaction with vaginal delivery. A participant expressed her satisfaction as: ‘’I was generally satisfied and comfortable. They told me I could get off the bed, use the restroom, sit on the therapy ball to relieve my labor pains, use oxygen. They were helpful. I was also allowed to walk around the corridor and walk in the room. I had freedom.’’
Regarding aggressive interaction such as misbehavior and unaccountability of staff and nurses demoralizing and discouraging the mothers, one participant stated that: ‘’They were always nagging with mistreatment. They told me ‘stop being corny, it’s not your first-time delivery; you’ve already had two kids, why thinking of the third?’; you know they misbehaved as such but I had to tolerate.’’
Confrontation with fear and anxiety
This theme had two sub-themes of ‘’fear’’ and ‘’anxiety from the risks of childbirth and newborn baby’’. Maternal concern over the healthy birth of the newborn baby could have an inhibitory effect on their satisfaction with vaginal delivery. A participant who was constantly worried about her baby being injured during delivery stated that: ‘’I was only thinking what if my baby wouldn’t survive while I’m tolerating such a great pain and hardship. God forbid, perhaps I’d be depressed if something bad happened.’’
Being stressed out due to mother’s history of an unpleasant vaginal delivery or fear from C-section has disturbed the mind of some mothers. Despite already passing two deliveries, a mother was still stressful and expressed that: ‘’my 3rd-time birth-giving was more worrying because I’ve had the experience and knew what a painful moment I’m going to go through. I was already stressful but became more scared as I got to the hospital.’’
Desire to hug a healthy baby
This theme included two subthemes of the ‘’desire to give birth to a healthy baby’’ and the ‘’desire to hug a healthy baby’’ affecting maternal satisfaction with vaginal delivery. Hoping that God would bestow her a healthy baby as per the huge pain she was incurring, a mother was confident of delivering a healthy baby and declared that: ‘’It feels good when the baby is healthy and pretty. You incur the pain and hardship and God will give you a good one.’’
Another mother proposed that hugging her baby is the key secret to a happy life. She stated that: ‘’When the baby is born, all pains go away. You feel calm. When it’s born it’s sweet and enjoyable. I’ve never felt such a lovely pleasure.’’
Discussion
The present study was conducted on nulliparous and multiparous women who gave birth in both state and private hospitals. The participants had various academic and economic levels, which was one of the strengths of the present study. Women’s experiences of factors affecting their satisfaction with vaginal delivery were structured based on seven themes, namely ‘’desire to record the unique experience of childbirth’’, ‘’underlying cultural beliefs on childbirth’’, ‘’understanding of the nature of labour pain’’, ‘’confrontation with ignorance’’, ‘’interaction environment: from support to aggression’’, ‘’confrontation with fear and anxiety’’ and ‘’desire to hug a healthy baby.’’ Provided that the patients felt okay, they were interviewed within 6 to 48 hours after childbirth in the breastfeeding room of the same ward with cooperation of the staff. According to the results of the present study, the enthusiasm and love for experiencing vaginal delivery was a significant factor affecting the satisfaction with vaginal delivery especially in nulliparous women. Most of the subjects were satisfied with their opportunity to consciously apprehend all procedures of delivery and vigilantly saw their baby while being delivered. In their quantitative study, Goodman et al. determined factors affecting maternal satisfaction with childbirth in the US. They found that women’s personal control over labor was a substantial predictor of their satisfaction, subscales included, with vaginal delivery.. Guittier et al. conducted a qualitative study on the effect of delivery mode on the childbirth experience of nulliparous women. They indicated that emotional apprehension and control over the first contact with the newborn baby was one of the most important factors affecting a desirable vaginal delivery experience compared with C-section delivery19. The participants of the present study whose feelings of getting older, becoming more patient and more tolerant of life difficulties, triggered by their vaginal labour pain, marked the insignificance of the pain were more satisfied with vaginal delivery. The tendency to follow medical instructions, such as attracting the midwife’s attention by heartily listening to her commands, also played a crucial role in satisfaction with vaginal delivery. The aforesaid results were consistent with the findings of Mekonnen et al. who displayed that women following the advices of medical staff and nurses to receive necessary information, were more satisfied with their childbirth20. In the present study, most mothers who expressed more fears and anxiety about vaginal delivery due to their awareness of delivery stages and process through watching videos of vaginal birth declared that being less informed about the nature of vaginal delivery had made them less stressful while more satisfied with their vaginal childbirth. Therefore, regarding maternal stress and fear of vaginal delivery, Fenwick stated that specialized training courses held by such professionals as nurses can have a significant impact on pregnant women. Such courses should depict vaginal delivery portray in such a way asto promote confidence in pregnant women and teach them how to control their fear21. Corresponding to the findings of Hodnett22 and Lally23, the results of the present study demonstrated that while their delivery conditions proceeded better than expected, those women whose expectation for a painful experience made them more realistic and less romantic about vaginal delivery became more satisfied than those with a delivery experience worse than expected.
According to the present study, confrontation with ignorance including unfamiliarity with the hospital environment and unfamiliarity with childbirth procedures and rules contributed to maternal dissatisfaction while the succor of an assistant midwife until the delivery time led to maternal satisfaction. Likewise, Raven et al. found that quality childbirth cares and rules, increased sense of responsibility and intimate communication between service providers and service receivers, and their families, were considered as vital and effective factors in maternal decision making during childbirth in China24.
Furthermore, Sawyer et al. indicated that staff competency in conveying information and explanation had a significant impact on maternal satisfaction25. In their study entitled ‘’the satisfaction rate of vaginal delivery and related factors in Mahdieh Hospital in Tehran and Shahid Chamran hospital in Boroujerd’’, Dolatian et al. (2006) found that satisfactory childbirth environment was one of the best predictor of maternal satisfaction26,37. Based on the results of the present study, the interaction environment from support to aggression was a crucial factor affecting childbirth satisfaction which was also highlighted in other studies. The current participants demanded extensive supports during their labour process accentuating the insufficiency of merely scientific and midwifery approach to maternal satisfaction. That is, they required emotional support and empathic behavior on the part of medical staff and associates to help them adapt to the labour pain they are incurring. In Gamble’s et al. quantitative study, the participants prioritized the relationship with care providers27. Waldenstrom et al. displayed that staff support and attentiveness to the would-be mother during labour was highly vital in Sweden28. Similarly, Sawyer stated that staff competency, calmness in crisis, portraying confidence and control in addition to solely listening to the would-be mother, empathy, emotional support and encouragement as well as the succor of father during childbirth significantly affected maternal satisfaction25,36. Moreover, staff support and communication especially on midwife’s part, was a significant and solid predictor of maternal satisfaction with childbirth experience26,29. The present study showed that aggressive interaction such as staff misbehavior and unaccountability demoralized and dissatisfied the mother-to-be. Likewise, Beck found that negative communication and lack of support can be accounted as one of the causes of postpartum traumatic disorders and tensions30,35. According to Karlstrom, firs-time childbirth experience had a vital significance in maternal attitude towards subsequent pregnancies to which the attentiveness of medical staff in delivery room is highly appreciated31. Maternal concern over the healthy birth of the newborn baby could also have an inhibitory effect on their satisfaction with vaginal delivery. Most of them were often worried about the potential risks during childbirth triggering a negative attitude towards vaginal delivery and the demand for C-section delivery. The aforesaid findings were consistent with the results of Karlstrom indicating that being stressed out during labour as well as having a prolonged delivery led mothers to fear and agony and increased their inclination to C-section delivery31,34. Similarly, Vaziri et al. demonstrated that highly stressful mothers adopted a new negative outlook towards vaginal delivery during childbirth and disapproved it for prospective mothers32. In line with the study of Kassai et al. in Brazil23, the participants of the present study presented a satisfactory expression for vaginal delivery contributed to rapid recovery and return to normal life so as to immediately participate in caring the newborn baby as well as their inexperience of caesarean-related pain and suffering.
Conclusion
The results of the present study indicated that satisfaction with vaginal delivery is multifactorial and reflective of several peripheral aspects associated with the positive key factors imposing various effects with negative outcomes included as well. Therefore, identifying the structure and process of maternal satisfaction with vaginal delivery in Iran would assist the necessity of appropriate cultural strategies for implementing effective interventions to enhance maternal satisfaction with vaginal delivery. It would also promote them through holding childbirth preparation training courses on non-pharmacological prevention and relief of labor pain to make vaginal delivery an enjoyable and indelible experience for women. Besides, midwives and medical staff are highly recommended to pay considerable attention to the psychological and supportive needs of the would-be mothers with their physical health prioritized.
Agradecimientos
Hereby, the researcher of the present study would like to express their sincere gratitude to all the participants, without whom this study would be in vain, and earnestly appreciate the management and staff of Fatemieh (PBUH) hospital affiliated to Hamedan University of Medical Sciences, Booali private hospital and Atieh hospital affiliated to Social Security Organization in Hamedan province.
References
1. Fisher C, Hauk Y, Fenwick J. How social context impacts on women’s fears of childbirth: A western Australian example. Soc Sci and Med. 2006; 63 (1): 64-75.
2. Farr SL, Jamieson DJ, Rivera HV, Ahmed Y, Heilig CM. Risk factors for cesarean delivery among Puerto Rican women. Obstet Gynecol. 2007; 109(6):1351-1357.
3. Goodman P, Mackey MC, Tavakoli AS. Factors related to childbirth satisfaction. J Adv Nurs. 2004; 46:212–19.
4. Mirmawlai T, Mehran A., Rahimi Gasabeh S. Mother's opinions concerning the importance of and their satisfaction with support received in the labor and delivery rooms. The Journal of Faculty of Nursing & Midwifery. 2004; 9(17): 41-48.
5. Lundgren I. Swedish women’s experiences of doula support during childbirth. Midwifery.2010; 26 (2): 173- 80.
6. Javadnoori M, Afshari P, Montazeri S, Latifi SM. The effect of continuous labor support by accompanying person during labor process. Scientific Medical Journal of Ahvaz University of Medical Sciences.2008; 7 (50): 32- 38. [Persian]
7. Harvey S, Rach D, Stainton MC, Jarrell J, Brant R. Evaluation of satisfaction with midwifery care. Midwifery. 2002; 18(5):260-7.
8. Moudi Z, Tavousi M. Evaluationof Mackey Childbirth Satisfaction Rating Scale in Iran: What Are the Psychometric Properties? Nurs Midwifery Stud 2016.InPress (InPress):e29952.doi: 10.17795/nmsjournal29952
9. Naghizadeh S, Sehhati F, Atri Barjange SH, Ebrahimi H. Comparing mothers’ satisfaction from ethical dimension of care providedin labor, delivery, and postpartum phases in educational and non-educational hospitals. Journal of Research & Health Social Development & Health Promotion Research Center. 2011; 1(1): 25-33
10. Campell DA, Lake MF, Falk M. A Randomized Control Trail of Continuous Support during Lab by a Lay Doula. J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs.2006; 35: 456-64.
11. Hidaka R, Callister LC. Giving Birth with Epidural Analgesia: The Experience of First-Time Mothers. The Journal of Perinatal Education. 2012; 21(1):24-35.
12. Clivatti J, Siddiqui N, Goel A, Shaw M, Crisan I, Carvalho J. C. A. Quality of labour neuraxial analgesia and maternal satisfaction at a tertiary care teaching hospital: a prospective observational study. J Can Anesth .2013; 60:787–795.
13. Elo S, Kyngas H. The qualitative content analysis process. J Adv Nurs 2008; 62(1): 107-15
14. Streubert HJ, Carpenter DR. Qualitative research in nursing: Advancing the humanistic imperative Historical Research Method. 5rd ed. Wolters Kluver/Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins: Philadelphia; 2011.
15. Granehim UH, Lundman B. Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: concepts, procedures and measuares to achieve trusthworthiness, Journal of Nurse Education Today. 2004; 24(2):105-12
16. Polit DF, Beck CT. Study guide to accompany essentials of nursing research: Methods, appraisal, and utilization. 6th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2006.
17. Hsieh HF, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res .2005;15(9):1277-88. 23
18. Morse JM, Barrett M, Mayan M, Olson K, Spiers J. Verification Strategies for Establishing Reliability and Validity in Qualitative Research. International Journal of Qualitative Methods 2002;1:13-22
19. Guittier MJ, Cedraschi Ch, Jamei N, Boulvain M ,Guillemin F. Impact of mode of delivery on the birth experience in first-time mothers: a qualitative study. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth.2014;14:254
20. Mekonnen ME, Yalew WA, Anteneh ZA. Women’s satisfaction with childbirth care in Felege Hiwot Referral Hospital, Bahir Dar city, Northwest Ethiopia, 2014: cross sectional study. BMC Res Notes .2015; 8:528.
21. Fenwick J, Hauck Y, Downie J, Butt J. The childbirth expectations of a self- selected cohort of western Australian women. Midwifery. 2005; 21 (1): 23- 35.
22. Hodnett ED. Pain and women's satisfaction with the experience of childbirth: a systematic review. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2002; 186 (5 Suppl Nature):S160-72.
23. Lally JE, Murtagh MJ, Macphail S, Thomson R. More in hope than expectation: a systematic review of women's expectations and experience of pain relief in labour. BMC Medicine. 2008; 6:7.
24. Raven J, van den Broek N, Tao F, Kun H, Tolhurst R. The quality of childbirth care in China: women’s voices: a qualitative study. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth .2015; 15:113.
25. Sawyer A, Rabe H, Abbott J, Gyte G, Duley L, Ayers S. Parents’ experiences and satisfaction with care during the birth of their very preterm baby: a qualitative study. BJOG. 2013; 120:637–643.
26. Dolatian M, Siami F, Khodakarami N, Simbar M. The satisfaction rate of vaginal delivery and related factors. Pejouhandeh. 2006; 13(3):259-268.
27. Gamble J, Creedy DK, Teakle B. Women’s expectations of maternity services: a community-based survey. Women and Birth. 2007; 20 (3): 115-20.
28. Waldenstrom U, Hildingsson I, Rubertsson C, Radestad I: A negative birth experience: prevalence and risk factors in a national sample. Birth.2004; 31(1):17-27.
29. Hodnett ED. Pain and women's satisfaction with the experience of childbirth: a systematic review. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2002; 186 (5 Suppl Nature):S160-72.
30. Beck C, Watson S. Subsequent childbirth after a previous traumatic birth. Nurs Res. 2010; 59 (4): 241-49
31. Karlstrom A, Nystedt A, Johansson M. Behind the myth- few women prefer caesarean section in the absence of medical or obstetrical factors. Midwifery. 2011; 27 (5): 620-27
32. F. Vaziri1, Z. Khademian2, B. Morshed Behbahani2. Qualitative investigation of experiences and perception of primiparous women regarding childbirth in women referring to educational hospitals of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences. Birjand journal of Nursing and Midwifery .2013;9(3).
33. Kassai KE, Nomura RMY, Benute GRG, Lucia MCS. Women’s opinions about mode of birth in Brazil: a qualitative study in a public teaching hospital. Midwifery. 2010; 26 (3): 319-26.
34. Rabbani, M., Bagherzadeh, N., & Rafiei, H. (2014). Calculating raw material and work-in-process inventories in MTO. MTS production, UCT Journal of Research in Science, Engineering and Technology, 2(3): 109-116.
35. Ajallooeian, E., Gorji, Y., & Niknejadi, F. (2015). Evaluate the Effectiveness of Social Skills Training through Group Therapy Play on Reducing Rational Aggression Boy Elementary School Student in Esfahan City.UCT Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Research, 3(1), 1-4.
36. Akar E, Batçık KE, Acar C, Ton Ö, Canaz H, Baydın S, et al. A Comparative Analysis of the Effects of Melatonin and Nimodipine on Vasospasm. J Clin Exp Invest. 2018;9(3):113-8.
37. Al-Esami, H. H., AL-Ramadhan, Z., Ahmed, A. S., Shihab, Z., & Farhan, F. K. (2018). Improve the surface hardness of the blend PMMA/n-MgTiO3 to resist caries and bacteria. Electronic Journal of General Medicine, 15(6).
Author notes
khakbaza@sina.tums.ac.ir