ABSTRACT
Objective: the study sought to identify, in national and international publications, the principal Nursing interventions aimed at patients with intracranial hypertension.
Materials and Method: integrative literature review with search in LILACS, PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Cinahal, and Google Scholar databases, from 2013 to 2018.
Results: the sample was comprised of seven articles fulfilling the inclusion criteria. Two thematic categories were established for the Nursing interventions aimed at patients with intracranial hypertension: cognitive skills and clinical reasoning, necessary to control neuro-physiological parameters and prevent intracranial hypertension, and evidence-based practices to improve care for neuro-critical patients.
Conclusions: intracranial hypertension is an event of great clinical impact, whose complications can be minimized and control through specific Nursing interventions that encompass control of neuro-physiological and hemodynamic parameters and prevention of increased intracranial pressure related with the performance of procedures by the Nursing staff.
KEYWORDS (Source DeCS): Hemodynamic monitoring, intracranial pressure, nursing care management, nursing care, nursing.
RESUMEN
Objetivo: el estudio tiene como objetivo identificar, en publicaciones nacionales e internacionales, las principales intervenciones de Enfermería dirigidas a pacientes con hipertensión intracraneal.
Materiales y método: revisión integradora de la literatura con búsqueda en las bases de datos LILACS, PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Cinahal y Google Académico, del 2013 al 2018.
Resultados: la muestra se conformó de siete artículos que cumplieron con los criterios de inclusión. Se establecieron dos categorías temáticas para las intervenciones de Enfermería dirigidas a pacientes con hipertensión intracraneal: habilidades cognitivas y razonamiento clínico, necesarias para el control de parámetros neurofisiológicos y la prevención de hipertensión intracraneal, y prácticas basadas en evidencias para la mejora de la asistencia al paciente neurocrítico.
Conclusiones: la hipertensión intracraneal es un evento de gran repercusión clínica, cuyas complicaciones se pueden minimizar y controlar mediante intervenciones de Enfermería específicas que abarcan controles de parámetros neurofisiológicos, hemodinámicos y prevención de aumento de la presión intracraneal relacionado a la realización de procedimientos por el equipo de Enfermería.
PALABRAS CLAVE (Fuente: DeCS): Monitorización hemodinámica, presión intracraneal, cuidados de enfermería, atención de enfermería, enfermería.
RESUMO
Objetivo: este estudo objetiva identificar, nas publicações nacionais e internacionais, as principais intervenções de Enfermagem direcionadas a pacientes com hipertensão intracraniana.
Materiais e método: revisão integrativa da literatura com busca nas bases de dados LILACS, PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Cinahal e Google Acadêmico, de 2013 a 2018.
Resultados: a amostra foi constituída por sete artigos que atenderam aos critérios de inclusão. Elencaram-se duas categorias temáticas para as intervenções de Enfermagem direcionadas ao paciente com hipertensão intracraniana: habilidades cognitivas e raciocínio clínico, necessárias para o controle de parâmetros neurofisiológicos e para a prevenção de hipertensão intracraniana, e práticas baseadas em evidências para a melhoria da assistência ao paciente neurocrítico.
Conclusões: a hipertensão intracraniana é um evento de grande repercussão clínica, cujas complicações podem ser minimizadas e controladas mediante intervenções de Enfermagem específicas que abrangem controles de parâmetros neurofisiológicos, hemodinâmicos, bem como prevenção de aumento da pressão intracraniana atrelado à realização de procedimentos pela equipe de Enfermagem.
PALAVRAS-CHAVE (Fonte DeCS): Monitorização hemodinâmica, pressão intracraniana, cuidados de enfermagem, assistência de enfermagem, enfermagem.
Articles
Nursing Interventions for Patients with Intracranial Hypertension: Integrative Literature Review
Intervenciones de Enfermería para pacientes con hipertensión intracraneal: revisión integradora de la literatura
Intervenções de Enfermagem para pacientes com hipertensão intracraniana: revisão integrativa da literatura
Carolina Marques de Almeida
Camila Fernandes Pollo
Silmara Meneguin s.meneguin@unesp.br
Received: 07 May 2019
Revised document received: 15 August 2019
Accepted: 09 September 2019
Intracranial pressure (ICP) is an event of great clinical repercussion that attacks patients with brain tumors, severe brain injury, and extensive ischemic and hemorrhagic cerebral vascular accident. Increased ICP is a major cause of secondary cerebral lesion and is frequently associated with worsened neurological evolution 1-3.
Conceptualized as cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pressure from blood and brain tissue pressure, normal values range from 5 to 15 mmHg. 4. In critically ill patients, ICP may vary due to changes in blood pressure, ventilation, patient positioning, as well as changes in carbon dioxide and oxygen pressures 5. Increased ICP, above 20 mmHg, has as an important physiological repercussion in the reduction of cerebral perfusion pressure and cerebral blood flow, in addition to compressing brain structures and contributing to hydrocephalus, besides causing brain herniation 6-9.
Intracranial pressure monitoring by implanting a polyethylene catheter into the ventricular cavity connected to a pressure transducer is critical to prevent secondary brain damage that contributes to increased morbidity and mortality 10-13. Despite being an invasive procedure that involves health and safety risks to those who use it, it is the only accepted method for the safe diagnosis of increased ICP, as well as for its treatment in some clinical situations 14-16.
Added to the control of clinical, hemodynamic, respiratory, and metabolic parameters, monitoring the ICP helps and guides the therapy of neurological patients, as it allows for its rapid recognition and permits assessing the therapeutic efficacy, as well as brain injury 17-18.
Although catheter insertion is an inherent procedure for the neurosurgery team, its care and ICP monitoring are the responsibilities of the intensive care unit (ICU) nursing staff 19.
In addition, it should be considered that the nurse is the bedside professional giving meaning to the ICP monitoring parameters, through theoretical knowledge, logical reasoning, and experience acquired in practice 20. Care consistent with knowledge and practices combined with educational and care actions in the professional practice to ensure the quality of care provided to neuro-critical patients 21.
In the ICU, Nursing professionals should avoid unnecessary harm during health care delivery to improve the care provided and prevent iatrogenesis 22-23. Iatrogenic events, within this context, may put patient at risk of life and bring complications that may compromise their clinical course and safety 24.
It should be noted that increased ICP often occurs as a result of routine nursing procedures, such as bed bath, patient positioning, and oral and bronchial hygiene, among others 25-26. In this sense, the nursing staff should be aware of signs and symptoms of worsening intracranial hypertension, which depend on the location of the brain injury. However, the most common symptom is worsening mental state 27-29.
In this sense, systematization of Nursing care (SNC) is an important tool, given that it permits the Nursing staff to organize and direct their practice to the specific needs of each patient and prevent unnecessary harm 30.
Considering that the quality of health care is linked to the incorporation of good nursing practices, this study sought to know the interventions directed to patients with ICP monitoring to contribute to care based on scientific principles and the best evidence.
The objective of this study was to identify, in national and international publications, the principal Nursing interventions aimed at patients with intracranial hypertension.
Integrative literature review, conducted in five stages: problem identification, literature search, data evaluation, data analysis, and presentation of integrative review or synthesis of knowledge 31-32. To conduct this study, the following question was used: “What nursing interventions are described in the scientific literature for patients with intracranial hypertension?”
To search for the articles, on-line access was used to the following databases: Latin American and Caribbean Literature in Health Sciences (LILACS, for the term in Spanish), PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Cinahal, and Google Scholar. The descriptors selected from the list of Health Sciences Descriptors (DeCS) were: “hemodynamic monitoring”, “intracranial pressure”, “Nursing care” and “Nursing assistance”, “Nursing interventions”, “neuro-intensive care”, with Boolean operators OR and AND.
The search was carried out in December 2018. To include the articles, the following criteria were considered: original articles that addressed the guiding question, published between 2013 and 2018, in Portuguese, English, and Spanish. Articles not available in full, experience reports, literature reviews, theses and dissertations were excluded.
In order to obtain more accurate results, the search was aided by two researchers involved in the study. For the data collection of the studies, an instrument was elaborated that included the following information: year of publication, authors, objective, country in which the study was carried out, database, research design, sample detailing, intervention, results and recommendation/conclusions. Such information contributed to the analysis and synthesis of the data obtained in the search.
The study initially identified 630 articles; of these, 380 were excluded because they were duplicated in the databases. Thus, 250 articles were selected to read the title and abstract, which resulted in a sample of 50 articles for full-text reading. Of these, 43 were excluded for not answering the guiding question, which lead to a total of seven articles (Figure 1). Four studies were conducted in the United States, two in Europe, and one in Brazil.
Table 1 presents the characteristics of the articles selected for this review, according to author, year of publication, database, research design, and results associated to Nursing interventions.
Figure 2 shows the structural synthesis of nursing interventions identified in the literature (Botucatu, Brazil, 2019).
The reading and analysis of the articles permitted observing that the Nursing interventions are linked to cognitive skills and clinical reasoning, but they should also be supported by practices based on the best scientific evidence.
The nurse’s cognitive skills and clinical reasoning are fundamental to interpret the neuro-physiological and hemodynamic parameters, prevent the increase of ICP during Nursing procedures, and administer the pharmacological therapy prescribed. However, it is in evidence-based practice (EBP) that care has the scientific support needed to improve care practice.
Caring for patients with neurological alterations is a big challenge for the whole Nursing staff. Patients with ICP require specific and continuous care in ICU and demand maximum attention from the health staff and minimum manipulation, in order to avoid possible deleterious injuries or aggravate those existing 20,39-41.
As prerequisite to monitor ICP, the nurse needs to be aware of the principles of monitoring, neuro-anatomy, and neurophysiology, as well as the pathophysiology of intracranial hypertension (ICH) 42. It is known that increased ICP may be associated with the patient’s clinical condition or may occur in response to routine Nursing care. Therefore, the focus of medical and nursing interventions should be the prevention or minimization of secondary brain injury 37,43-44.
A study conducted with 18 patients with neurosurgical diagnoses revealed that the most common types of secondary events after Nursing care were increased intracranial pressure, followed by a fall in cerebral perfusion pressure and mean blood pressure. The authors concluded that patients with increased risk of secondary events must be recognized and their care and treatment must be rigorously planned 36.
In this sense, the literature emphasizes the importance of Nursing empowerment in the multidisciplinary staff and the use of care protocols that include interventions to control and manage ICP to intervene briefly and effectively in treatments aimed at mitigating this event, as well as adjusting nursing procedures that, by association, may increase intracranial hypertension and decrease cerebral perfusion pressure 25-27.
In the survey conducted in this research, it was identified that nursing interventions are linked to cognitive skills and clinical reasoning, essential to interpret the monitoring parameters and implement care to control ICP.
The interventions described in the literature found during the search period are neuro-physiological and encompass monitoring of hemodynamic parameters, like oxygen saturation, mean blood pressure, temperature, ICP, and cerebral perfusion pressure.
This search identified two works that describe procedures that, indirectly, can contribute to increase ICP and whose scientific evidence supports the best care. One of the procedures is the elevation of the bed headboard and the body position. Although the only study that addressed the subject did not find a statistically significant change in ICP values with the bed headboard at 15, 30, and 45 degrees, as well as in the supine, right, and left lateral positions, the sample size of 30 patients was considered a research limitation 34. However, other investigations show that patients with increased ICP benefit from head elevation by 10, 15, 30, and 45 degrees compared to zero degrees 45-46.
The other procedure described in the literature that contributed to increasing ICP is oral hygiene. A study that analyzed the influence of this procedure in 23 patients with ICP monitoring showed statistically significant increase of this parameter during oral hygiene (p = 0.0031), but without clinical repercussion 38.
Although this review did not include the inclusion of articles on endotracheal aspiration, it is essential to contextualize this procedure, which may also lead to increased ICP. A clinical study aimed at determining the best aspiration technique (open versus closed system) with 32 neurosurgical patients, showed that patients aspirated with open system had significantly lower mean carbon dioxide partial pressure than those aspirated with closed system, but without significant difference 47-50.
A recent study concluded that while most articles show an increase in ICP above 20 mmHg, when using the open aspiration system, it is still unclear which is the best technique to maintain adequate cerebral perfusion pressure. For the authors, more studies are necessary to determine the best endotracheal aspiration technique for the Nursing practice 51-52.
Implementing EBP-based care is critical to achieving effectiveness, reliability, and safety in health practices 53-54. In this context, nurses play an important role in planning the care for neuro-critical patients, given that they require daily systematized evaluation 35,54.
Nurses should be very cautious, given that routine procedures can aggravate the neurological condition due to the increase in ICP and decrease in cerebral perfusion pressure. Therefore, professionals must be trained to provide safe and qualified care to critically ill patients, given the need for constant attention in the application of interventions for their recovery 20,33,55-59.
Thus, the neurological assessment is essential to identify Nursing diagnoses, a crucial stage to elaborate a care plan based on a theoretical framework, which guides and improves the practice, as well as directs nursing interventions and expected results 60-61. In addition, the underlying clinical decision to care is paramount to the quality and excellence of the nursing practice in neuroscience 62.
A limitation of this research was that of obtaining studies with small sample sizes; therefore, it is necessary to develop more robust studies on the theme.
Intracranial hypertension is an event of great clinical impact. Complications arising from this event can be minimized and controlled through specific nursing interventions that include controlling neuro-physiological and hemodynamic parameters, as well as preventing the increase of ICP, often linked to the performance of nursing procedures.
The results of this study also evidence the importance of the best evidence-based care practice to support the multifaceted care that neurological patients require in ICU and whose success depends on a cohesive inter-professional staff, which also recognizes the family as an integral part of health care.
Despite the number of publications on the pathophysiology, it was found that few studies address Nursing care to the family and the patient affected by this secondary lesion, which may evolve to death.
